• mohd.shakib@smanik.com
  • April 27, 2016
download (7)

My article in India Today DailyO.

The Supreme Court on April 22 stayed the Uttarakhand High Court order of April 21 revoking President’s Rule in the state till April 27. Just the day before, almost after a month-long hearing, the High Court bench that included a chief justice had quashed the Centre’s rule upholding the disqualification of nine Congress MLAs and directed former chief minister Harish Rawat to prove majority on the floor of the Assembly on April 29.

The High Court, in its hearing, made scathing remarks about the Union government’s handling of the situation:

“Even the President can go wrong” in taking such decisions based on inputs of executive.

“There was no material. We are shocked at that decision-making at the highest level, involving the Cabinet and President… It was a blatant falsehood.”

“Absolute power can spoil anybody’s mind”.

Within a day, Supreme Court stayed the order and made scathing remarks against the High Court:

“What has been happening is a very serious and grievous matter for any state…you don’t revoke President’s rule just like that. Everything has to be looked into…a balance has to be struck.”

“If I were the High Court judge, I would have made my judgment operational only after three or four days when it is signed and ready. It is more on propriety than legality. Governance of a state cannot be left in the lurch.”

The developments over the past couple of days have left the layperson baffled. What’s happening in our country? The highest court is staying the order of the second highest court given by the judge at the highest level of the court. The Supreme Court, by making the above observations, is also hinting that high courts of the country are not capable of dealing with the complex issue. If that’s the case, it should pass strictures that such matters can be heard only by the Constitution bench of Supreme Court. If the court was not happy with the way things were being handled by the high court, it should have intervened in the matter suo motto.

This raises bigger concerns about the process of appeal in our country. Each and every judgement of the lower courts has the potential to go through an appeal process and this ensures it takes years for the final order.

The court also made reference to the propriety of the high court judge’s action of not providing the final judgement copy. There is no rule to provide the final judgement copy on the same day, this is indeed a lacuna.

If the Supreme Court is concerned about this then it should pass an order to the lower courts to the effect. One line of argument is how can a person file an appeal if he doesn’t have the final copy of the order and on what basis? This was sufficient ground to reject the appeal by central government. After all, the order given was not in haste. The high court discussed the matter for close to a month before delivering its final judgement.

The court’s reference to governance cannot be left in the lurch is also intriguing. How does this order help the governance of the state? In fact it creates a lot of confusion and adds to the chaotic situation the state is facing for the past one month as shown in the table below.

This is not the only incidence where courts have given flip-flop orders. On March 29, a single-member bench of Uttarakhand High Court had ordered a floor test to be conducted on March 31 without staying the President’s Rule based on a plea filed by Harish Rawat. It was hotly debated as to how floor test can happen parallelly with a central rule in the state. The very next day on March 30, a two-member division bench comprising the chief justice stayed the floor test order of the single-member bench.

With the matter in Supreme Court, two things can happen now. Either the Supreme Court allows the state to contiue to be under the President’s Rule or agrees with the high court order that the central rule should be quashed. The list of chief ministers of the state would show the following trend in both the cases:


Looking at the above table, does it seem like the Supreme Court order has helped governance? People could argue that we should not question court judgements, but what about our freedom of expression?

If Supreme Court overturns the high court order, it would raise serious questions about the ability of judges of our lower courts in handling matters of constitutional crisis. This brings us to the bigger issue of training of judges and the evolution of an appraisal process, which includes metrics such as orders overturned by higher courts to the total orders issued by the respective judge.

While the judiciary is considered to be the saviour of this country due to activism witnessed in recent years, a lot more trasparency needs to be built into the entire machinery. It needs serious overahaul of its organisation to smoothen the judicial process and deliver quality judgement within a reasonable time frame, which stands the test of all courts in the country.

A similar situation prevailed during the Arunachal crisis – one court overturned another court’s order and so on. It is clear that even after the Bommai case and Sarkaria Commission recommendations, the application of President’s Rule and its juducial review are very hazy and unclear as witnessed in the Arunachal as well as Uttarakhand crises.

The Supreme Court needs to take a serious look at the current lacunae in the system like the Parliament approval within two months when a government is in minority in the Upper House.

We all look up to you as one of the three pillars of our democracy. However, incidents like this do leave the common man confused about justice. Here you can’t blame the police/investigating agencies, its just an application of law.


best android app for downloading music

best android app for downloading music 2017-09-08 16:44:08/ Reply

Je chérit cette photographie toutefois j’en ai avant cela vu de semblable de meilleures modalités http://www.iomoio.net

tubidy free music downloads mobile

tubidy free music downloads mobile 2017-09-07 10:45:05/ Reply

You are my inhalation , I own few blogs and rarely run out from to post : (. http://www.iomoio.net

ed sheeran 2017

ed sheeran 2017 2017-09-04 20:24:03/ Reply

Hiya. Very cool web site!! Man .. Beautiful .. Superb .. I’ll bookmark your web site and take the feeds also…I’m glad to find a lot of useful info here in the article. Thank you for sharing.. http://www.edsheeran.co.uk

Visit Website

Visit Website 2016-11-01 02:27:59/ Reply

I simply want to tell you that I am all new to blogs and honestly savored this blog. Very likely I’m want to bookmark your blog . You absolutely come with excellent well written articles. Many thanks for sharing your web page.

Alberto Gilardino

Alberto Gilardino 2016-09-29 04:44:51/ Reply

Simply just wanted to express I'm thrilled I came in your internet page!. Alberto Gilardino http://www.ukrboard.biz.ua/user/profile/42233

brain smart

brain smart 2016-09-15 12:24:49/ Reply

I really liked your post.Really looking forward to read more. Awesome.

light deprivation greenhouse

light deprivation greenhouse 2016-09-05 08:41:49/ Reply

This is one awesome blog.Really looking forward to read more. Fantastic.

taxi free

taxi free 2016-09-04 03:10:43/ Reply

I really liked your article post.

payday loans

payday loans 2016-08-27 05:44:58/ Reply

Very neat article post.Really thank you! Great.

cheap loans

cheap loans 2016-08-27 03:14:12/ Reply

I think this is a real great article.Thanks Again. Cool.

payday loans

payday loans 2016-08-26 23:31:50/ Reply

Im thankful for the article post. Fantastic.

crowdfunding services

crowdfunding services 2016-08-26 08:18:10/ Reply

Great blog.Much thanks again. Much obliged.

nonton online

nonton online 2016-08-23 13:55:45/ Reply

I cannot thank you enough for the blog.Really looking forward to read more. Keep writing.

film semi

film semi 2016-08-23 10:43:41/ Reply

Im grateful for the article post.Really thank you! Much obliged.

madden nfl 17

madden nfl 17 2016-08-19 18:26:48/ Reply

Your knowledge is incredibly intriguing madden nfl 17 http://vidaexterior.es/EmilyEve/blog/13996/

Watch Australia Rugby Live Stream

Watch Australia Rugby Live Stream 2016-08-19 09:09:07/ Reply

Fantastic blog article.Much thanks again. Really Cool.

pokemon go

pokemon go 2016-08-17 18:59:52/ Reply

Good site you have here pokemon go http://www.adsagar.com/item/6099

fifa 17 coins

fifa 17 coins 2016-08-16 03:16:17/ Reply

Just wanted to emphasize I'm just grateful I came on the site!. fifa 17 coins http://harleytrader.ca/ads/buy-fifa-17-coins-the-game-companies/

bookies in the uk

bookies in the uk 2016-08-14 23:31:42/ Reply

Thank you ever so for you blog article. Fantastic.

softcore porn

softcore porn 2016-08-01 17:06:55/ Reply

Thanks for the blog.Really thank you! Keep writing.


hardcore 2016-07-31 16:01:28/ Reply

I value the blog. Much obliged.

muscle shirt

muscle shirt 2016-07-24 10:29:25/ Reply

Thank you ever so for you post.Much thanks again. Much obliged.

rrb result 2016

rrb result 2016 2016-07-16 19:14:27/ Reply

I really liked your blog article.Thanks Again. Want more.


seo 2016-07-16 06:25:16/ Reply

Appreciate you sharing, great post. Fantastic.

plantas purificadoras de agua

plantas purificadoras de agua 2016-07-12 11:39:58/ Reply

Muchos Gracias for your article. Fantastic.

BayrampaÅŸa evden eve nakliyat

BayrampaÅŸa evden eve nakliyat 2016-07-12 08:54:13/ Reply

Major thankies for the article.Really thank you! Cool.


www.mypsychicadvice.com/ 2016-07-12 06:08:21/ Reply

Thanks so much for the post.Thanks Again. Will read on...

Post a Comment


BlogAdda Indian Elections Page


FaceBook Page


  • Total Visit: 3,055,436


Author Page

PB Speaks To The Guardian

PB Oye Times Interview

Follow me on Twitter